Jump to content
AutoDesSys Forums
Spannerhead

Texture mapping in 8.6.2 is making me ragey...

Recommended Posts

...what the heck happened?  In 6.x it is so simple:  Textures and decals.  Apply global textures to an object with texture mapping, and then to individual faces with decals.  I could---and did frequently---apply multiple decals to a face. 

 

I design point-of-purchase displays for a living so I use the heck out of this feature.

 

Where is the decal tool in 8.6.2?  Please tell me they didn't do away with it.  If the new version doesn't have a comparable function, it will be borderline unusable for me.  And please don't tell me to create a separate object, apply the texture to that and group it.  I want to be able to create a piece of translucent acrylic, for instance, and apply 3 different brand logos, screen-printed, on it.  One object.  In 6.x this is easy as cake.

 

Sorry for the rant.  It just seems like they took something that was "fixed" and broke it for no reason.  Thanks for any and all help.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Thank you Andy.

 

Guess I'm going to have to get used to this Workspace thing.  Really confused as to why they had to complicate what was a beautifully simple control layout...

Edited by Spannerhead

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The entire "decal map" thing needs to go away. 

We should be able to apply any map in the same workspace, and see it real time without the need to render it.

FZ also needs to support Photoshop layers.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Decals are really just a workaround for proper modeling and mapping.  They don't work in OpenGL based Shaded modes, nor VRAY, nor any other rendering engine but RenderZone.  If you're happy with the old school results of RenderZone, feel free to keep using them.  You can customize your main workspace to add these tools and any others using the Tool Manager under Workspace>Tool Manager, without having to ever switch workspaces again (I never have to anymore).   I agree, the workspaces UI concept should be abandoned for a more modern UI.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that being able to see decals in Shaded Mode would be wonderful.  But the lack of ability to see them in any mode but RenderZone shouldn't be cause to do away with the function entirely.  Why not just FIX the issue so they can be previewed in those modes?  Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater, STS.

 

I'm perfectly satisfied with RenderZone's rendering quality, otherwise I wouldn't have purchased the whole package...  I work in the POP display industry, and I don't have the luxury to let VRay or Keyshot sit and churn for 30 minutes.  RenderZone powers through exactly what I need in less than half the time.

 

If, as you say, "Decals are really just a workaround for proper modeling and mapping," how would you map the attached WITHOUT decals?  Packaging labels on clear water bottles, screen printed translucent panels, etc.

 

Honestly curious.  Learn me.  :)

post-16422-0-92508200-1530056939_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like the way C4D handles "decals"... you are simply able to have textures overlap each other.  The "non-decal" is tiled, the "decal" doesn't tile and you can adjust it on your object accordingly.  This would be a welcomed addition to formZ. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Spannerhead-

 

I agree that Decals could have much better usefulness if they were also rendered in Shaded view and VRay.  FormZ = Flexibility.  There's often more than one way to do what you want with the power and flexibility of FormZ.

 

I would use Transparency Maps in place of your Decals.  I use this function a TON when placing logos on walls, signs, surfaces, etc... inside my branded environment designs.  It goes something like this...

 

First, you create your new logo Material with the appropriate logo file (Tiff or PNG), and set it's transparency to use the same image file's Alpha channel (If the logo doesn't have an Alpha Channel, go into Photoshop and create it.)  Now you have a material with the logo cutout.  FormZ logo example attached.

 

Then, make a plane geometry on top of your bottle surface, or wrapping the bottle like in this example.  Keep the plane just from touching the bottle, .01 tends work easy for keying this in quickly.  

 

Now turn OFF shadow casting on your new wrapper.

 

Apply your logo with alpha channel transparency material to the new wrapper.  Adjust mapping as appropriate.

 

Render.

 

post-219-0-18726800-1530126885_thumb.jpg

 

This is just a quick and dirty example, but you should be able to get something like this.  I'm using VRay with my 16 core AMD 1950x CPU,  This rendered in exactly 1 minute (time limit set in Vray).  That's plenty fast in my experience, so if you are only avoiding VRay because of the speed, you should reconsider if you have a modern workstation computer.  It's even faster with GPUs, but I turned those off for the simplicity of this example. 

 

You should be able to use the same technique with RenderZone.

 

Here's my files if you want to check it out - https://www.dropbox.com/s/p6i6172f0dgp343/bottle-FormZ.zip?dl=0

Edited by Justin Montoya

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I create transparency maps using the image's alpha channel all the time.  In fact it's how I created the bottle labels in the file I attached above...  Make the image the same height and width as a front view of the bottle and the label will be perfectly positioned once mapped to the dims of the bottle in formZ.

 

I understand the justification for your method from the standpoint of being able to preview the result in Shaded Interactive, but there are some drawbacks:

 

- Every time you want to move the bottle, you now have to move 2 objects instead of 1.  When using the Join tool so that objects can be moved together, properties like texture mapping and shadow casting get funky, in my experience.

- formZ often can't handle offsetting from a complex surface.  A simple bottle is usually OK, but what about a logo on a curved baseball cap?  Or a label on a whiskey bottle?  Etching on a wine glass?

 

Again, I can see some advantages, but to me, the technique you describe just seems to take 3 more steps and involve twice as many objects to achieve the same result as simply mapping a decal...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regarding VRay, as mentioned above, I've been satisfied with my RenderZone speed and quality so I haven't really felt the need to upgrade in that department...  If it ain't broke, don't fix it.  :)

 

I'm using a 2011 17" MacBook Pro.  I don't know the processor specs off the top of my head, but it's maxxed out and does just fine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like the way C4D handles "decals"... you are simply able to have textures overlap each other.  The "non-decal" is tiled, the "decal" doesn't tile and you can adjust it on your object accordingly.  This would be a welcomed addition to formZ. 

Mapping in C4D is a breeze. I also like it's sub-d modeling tools. Unfortunately, in my current position I am not allowed to use it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ctrl+G groups objects together without messing with their texture mapping or shadow casting.  Command+G for Apple is the default shortcut I believe.  

 

I've noticed that 8.6 moves grouped objects together by default (6.5 doesn't unless you have the "Group" topological level selected).  May have to take advantage of this.

 

 

Mapping in C4D is a breeze. I also like it's sub-d modeling tools. Unfortunately, in my current position I am not allowed to use it.

 

One of my coworkers uses C4D; seems like a nice program.  I do like the ability to choose whether texture maps OR decals are tiled, though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi again guys.  Thanks again for all your help.  Texture mapping is going pretty well.  Getting used to it.

 

One question at the moment:  When using flat mapping in 6.5 it was possible to set the texture map to automatically size itself to 1 tile across by 1 tile high on an object (see attached image).  Is this possible with 8.6.2?  If so, how?

post-16422-0-41810000-1532442131_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Spannerhead

 

it was handy :-(
I can set up in version 8 with the tool "edit texture map", (uncheck "lock size")
The "tile" option in the "Edit Texture Map Tool Options" has been removed ...
see attached image
One of those details that annoys me with this version 8
At worst, skip it in Junior but leave the PRO version ALL OPTIONS

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

sorry there is something wrong

forum soft don't load images pasted in the editing windows

so here as attached piece

 

 

 

+ Wrong massage when loading the image

+ I can't load the image to see it after posted

post-10360-0-28077100-1532618746_thumb.jpg

Edited by jldaureil

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I don't get it.  It was super handy, especially when mapping product.  I could create the map in Photoshop, import it into formZ and just set it to tile 1:1 on the object.  Done.

 

Now I have to visually guess if my texture map really fits over the whole object...  Annoying.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

I'm not sure I understand exactly what you're doing.
I have the impression that you prepare your map in photoshop in the proportion of the object that you target ...
For my part, I use it for the mapping of terrain with captured aerial photo on the site of our national service of geography.
It is enough that I know the size (in pixel for example) of my image, I create a corresponding rectangle, then I scale it then I use Get / Set attribute to project on the final mesh.
(it's easier to do than to explain it

I found the new tool "copy attribute" more "simplistic" necessarily ...
(be careful this is not a compliment)
Once again I do not find the new solution better and I explain why:

1- it works in reverse (first the target or targets, then the source)
It does not matter (but not logical for a Frenchman who has the habit of putting the adjective after the name and not the opposite)
But it's related to what I mean:

2- did you understand how you can adjust the copied parameters BEFORE assigning them?
in other words, can we modify the "attributes" before assigning them?

I use very often GET / SET attribute tools to assign multiple attributes simultaneously (surfaces styles (now materials) + layer + texture mapping etc ..)

In other words, how can we assign several attributes temporarily stored in a list (which is very good "GET" attribute in Z673) including the parameters of mapping in one go on several objects or only one of the choice and renew this operation as many time as needed keeping the same setting or modifying some?

With Get / Set attributes I can store a set of parameters to modify them in passing before assigning them multiple or not

In Formz 8 I can use the "attributes" options of the pick tool but I have to start again every time
With the copy attribute tool I do not see how to intervene on the copied parameters ...

 

 

Ps

Image forum : double right click > open in a new tab

it's like in form 8: simpler!

Edited by jldaureil

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No the maps I create in Photoshop don't have to have exactly the proportions as the object I'm mapping onto.  That was the beauty of the 1:1 tile option on the Texture Mapping menu.

 

For example, I'd be designing a display that holds potato chip bags.  There are several different flavors, and I have a map for each flavor.  I could just create the map at whatever size and proportions I choose, import it into formZ and slap it onto the chip bag object at 1:1 without having to position and size like I do now...

 

Really hope that functionality is still present.  Maybe it's just buried somewhere new?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes... the forums are messed up, pop up images seemed to be blocked, or not working... Tech are you seeing this?

 

Spannerhead,

 

I agree that the old detailed mapping was really nice, and it will hopefully be brought back in some sort in the future.  That said, the new Shaded interactive mapping is really fast once you get the hang of it.  Make sure you only have Point Snap turned ON, then simply drag the corners to snap a 1:1 on the object.  Is it as fast as the old way?   Probably not quite, but I actually really like this new Interactive way of mapping since it allows you to visualize changes to the mapping incase you find 1:1 isn't as ideal as you thought.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ok i fully understand what you are doing ...
on the other hand I do not really see where this option would have hidden!
nothing found in the manual

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.  Coming along with 8.6...  Lots of things I miss from 6.5 but I'm getting used to it.

 

I've made the transition fully with my home MacBook Pro I use for freelance, but now I'm finally setting up my work PC with 8.6.

 

Current issue is that Shaded Work and Shaded Full display as wireframe.....which is going to be make texture mapping pretty difficult, lol.  Any solutions?

 

Thanks again for any and all help!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Des,

Thanks for the reply.  I'm sorry I didn't reply sooner---for some reason I didn't have the subscription turned on for this thread.

I've attached a screencap of what Shaded Work looks like on my screen.  Here's a link to my test model:

https://we.tl/t-u8zJf2oS9e

Appreciate any and all help.  With all the glitches, formZ is not usable for me at the moment on my work PC.  Soldiering on with 6.6............

shadedwork.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×